Does Fudge Stick To Tin Foil?

does fudge stick to foil

No matter how skilled a baker you are, we have all experienced that horrible moment when your creation becomes stuck to the baking parchment or tin foil that you are using. This is especially frustrating when whatever it is that you are making becomes damaged in the process.

But, one thing that you might be wondering is if fudge sticks to tin foil. Depending on how wet the fudge mixture is and what ingredients you are using, may result in your fudge sticking to the tin foil. Whilst there are some alternatives that you can try – including silicone matts and waxed cloth – often tin foil is the best option for fudge making.

In this guide, we’ll be telling you all that you need to know about fudge sticking to tin foil. So, to find out more keep on reading.

Does Fudge Stick To Tin Foil?

As we have said, yes, fudge does stick to tin foil. Sometimes. It is often difficult to avoid your fudge sticking to the tin foil that you have used to make it. But, this will not happen all the time.

The majority of the time, whether or not this will happen depends entirely on the type of fudge that you are making, and how wet the mixture is. How wet the mixture is will depend on what ingredients that you are using. This is why it is impossible to state definitively if your fudge will stick to the tin foil that you are using.

So, what we can say is that there is a good chance that your fudge might stick to the tin foil that you are using. But, this does not always happen.

Should Fudge Stick To Tin Foil?

Seen as fudge regularly sticks to the tin foil that you use in the preparation process, you might be wondering if this should happen. In one short word, the answer is no. There are very few circumstances where whatever you are baking should stick to the tools that you are using. Fudge definitely isn’t one of them.

If your fudge sticks to the tin foil during the preparation process, this generally should be a cause for concern. Not only can it make things difficult for you, but if your fudge sticks to the tin foil, it can also damage the final finish of your fudge.

In an ideal world, fudge will have a solid square appearance when it is ready to enjoy. If it sticks to the tin foil then you will struggle to get this finish on your fudge.

So, no, your fudge shouldn’t stick to the tin foil. If this happens then this is generally a sign that there is something wrong with the mixture. Let’s take a look at what this could be.

Why Does Fudge Stick To Tin Foil?

There are a couple of different reasons why your fudge might stick to tin foil during the preparation/setting process.

Some recipes for fudge are naturally wetter than others, and it is these mixtures that most regularly stick to the tin foil. A lot of the time, this will be affected by the amount of butter that is included in the recipe, and if you have accidentally used too much.

If this is the cause, it is likely that the fudge mixture will stick to whatever you use to bake/set it in. Whether that be tin foil, baking parchment, or a silicone pan.

The other main reason why your fudge might stick to the tin foil is if it hasn’t been lubricated. As is often the case, you should prepare the equipment that you are using to bake before you add the mixture to it.

The same principle applies to fudge, so you should lightly butter the tin foil before adding the mixture if you want to avoid it sticking. This is a step that a lot of people forget about when they are making fudge, and this is one of the main reasons why their fudge then ends up sticking to the tin foil.

So, as you can see, there are a couple of reasons why your fudge might end up sticking to the tin foil that you use when setting it. As we have said, the main reason for this is the recipe that you are using.

Now, let’s take a quick look at how you can avoid this happening.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do You Keep Fudge From Sticking To Tin Foil?

Well, from what we have already said, it is likely that you have figured out the easiest way to avoid your fudge sticking to the tin foil. This is, of course, to butter the foil before you bake/set your fudge. So, let’s take a look at how to do this.

This is actually a very easy process. To begin with, all you need to do is line the inside of a baking pan with tin foil. Fit the foil to the inside of the baking pan and press down into the corners to ensure that it fits snugly. With that in place, take a paper towel and rub it in your butter.

Then lightly butter the foil that is fitted inside your pan, taking care to get right into the corners, as this is one of the worst places for sticking.

With this done, you can then add your fudge mixture and you shouldn’t have to worry about it sticking to the tin foil. This is because the butter will prevent this from happening, no matter whether you are cooling your fudge or putting it in the fridge to set.


As their names would suggest, tin foil is made from tin and aluminium foil is made from aluminium. Whilst they look very similar in appearance and are both used for packaging and baking purposes, tin foil is actually less sturdy, stiffer and often leaves a metallic taste in your mouth.

Therefore we would recommend using aluminium foil for your fudge as it is eco-friendly, has no distinguishing taste and is toxic free. Aluminium foil is often mistaken for tin foil due to the commonalities between the two.

IN Summary

In short, yes, fudge can stick to tin foil during the cooking/setting process, but this shouldn’t happen. The best way to avoid this happening is to lightly butter the foil before adding your mixture to the tin that you are using. You can find out more about this in the guide above.


Hi, I'm Sarah and welcome to Call Me Fudge! From a younger age I've always pottered about in the kitchen and even selling my fudge in the high school grounds. Cooking and baking to me is like second nature and I want to share this passion with you.

Recent Posts