Banoffee pie fudge recipe

banoffee pie fudge recipe- call me fudge

Whoever thought of combining toffee and bananas together, needs a medal. Seriously! Thick and rich toffee sauce encased in a buttery pastry shell, topped with freshly sliced banana and lashings of whipped cream. Absolutely divine!

To make banoffee pie flavour fudge, you start with a chocolate fudge base and flavour with sweet and creamy dulce de leche and chewy, dried banana pieces.

You can see why at Call Me Fudge, we wanted to incorporate this classic pudding into a fudge recipe!

Read on to find out how you can make your own batch of banoffee fudge…

Why is it called banoffee pie?

The banoffee pie was born from layers of toffee, bananas, cream and pastry. The main ingredients being banana and toffee, hence the name banoffee as the words conjoined.

What is Banoffee flavour?

The banoffee flavour, as you can imagine from the way it sounds, is a mixture of banana and toffee. The flavours are sweet and light when combined together.

Not a fan of the banoffee pie? Try our Apple pie fudge recipe instead!

Banoffee pie fudge recipe

Ever wondered what banoffee pie fudge tastes like? Us too. Make this fudge recipes and we’re sure you won’t be disappointed.

Bite into smooth chocolate fudge with crunchy textures of banana and biscuits. Smell and taste the sweetness of dulce de leche toffee complimenting the banana. Go on…make this fudge today!

What is great about this recipe is that although we have recommended ingredients, you may choose to substitute items for things you have in your larder already.

For example you may prefer digestive biscuits to shortbread and honeycomb to toffee.

Equipment and tools needed to make banoffee fudge

clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
banoffee pie fudge recipe

Banoffee pie fudge recipe

  • Author: Caroline
  • Prep Time: 15 minutes
  • Cook Time: 15 minutes
  • Total Time: 30 minutes
  • Yield: 36 pieces 1x


Units Scale


  • Start off by adding the chocolate chips, sweetened condensed milk and butter into your bowl.
  • Place the bowl of ingredients into the microwave and blast it for 40 second intervals. Make sure to remove the bowl each time to stir the ingredients.
  • Once all the chocolate has melted, give the ingredients a good stir with the spatula. The condensed milk and butter should all melt in easily.
  • Add in the corn syrup and stir again. The fudge mixture should be very thick at this point- almost pulling away from the sides of bowl.
  • Wait 5 minutes for the fudge mixture to cool slightly, so that the biscuits and candy don’t become soggy or melt. banoffee pie fudge ingredients
  • Now combine in the dried banana, the biscuits and chopped candy. add candy and banana to banoffee fudge
  • When these are thoroughly combined you will be able to add in 1 TBSP dulce de leche. add dulce de leche to banoffee fudge
  • Pour half of the fudge mixture into the prepared pan.
  • Swirl the rest of dulce de leche into the fudge mixture, this way the caramel doesn’t get lost in the mix and keeps its integrity.
  • Smooth the fudge over evenly with you spatula. layer banoffee fudge over ducle de leche
  • Top with your leftover banana chips, biscuits and candy. Press them in gently so they don’t come off easily when cutting. decorate banoffee fudge with banana pieces and shortbread
  • Let it cool completely before leaving it to chill it in the fridge.
  • After it has been left to chill in the fridge and the fudge is set, take it out and leave to sit on the counter top for 10 minutes. As there are quite a few textures in this banoffee fudge recipe it will be hard to cut through.
  • Take the fudge out the baking tray onto a cutting board.
  • Cut through the fudge with a sharp knife. You should get 36 squares out of this recipe. cut and serve banoffee pie fudge
  • Store in an airtight container for up to 2 weeks.

Alternatively, you can chop and change the ingredients according to your desired taste. You may wish to add another tablespoon of dulce de leche if you’ve got a sweet tooth for the taste of toffee. Or swap the semi sweet chocolate for bitter sweet or even white chocolate chips. For those who love banana fudge, go bananas and add in an extra handful of dried chips.

And although we chose to use dulce de leche due to it thick consistency for our recipe, you could swap this out for a toffee sauce or caramel.

If you’re a fan of the chunky monkey ice cream from Ben and Jerry’s, we’d especially like to recommend you go the extra mile by adding 1/4 cup chopped nuts of your choice. This would be so delicious we would we has thought of that when creating this recipe.

It is completely up to you!

In Summary

Crushed biscuits, toffee and banana all in a fudge. What’s not to like? You could even serve it as a mini dessert with some melted toffee sauce on the side. Or as petit four, this fudge makes the perfect accompaniment to an after dinner coffee – we recommend a mocha.

Of course, with acknowledgements to those who dislike banana we have the most perfect and delicious fudge recipes for you.

Find our other fudge recipes now:


Hi, I'm Sarah and welcome to Call Me Fudge! From a younger age I've always pottered about in the kitchen and even selling my fudge in the high school grounds. Cooking and baking to me is like second nature and I want to share this passion with you.

Recent Posts