10 Delicious Creamsicle Fudge Recipes

10 delicious creamsicle fudge recipes

Fudge is known for being consumed as a delicious holiday treat, and it can be enjoyed any time of the year. But Christmas and thanksgiving are just not complete without a taste of fudge to add to the dining table full of delights and wondrous creations, that the whole family can get stuck into.

Or if it’s a thanksgiving for one this year, you deserve to spoil yourself with the 10 most delicious creamsicle fudge recipes that you can rifle through to find the one that draws you in.

And if you’ve been fighting with the internet to find the best creamsicle fudge recipes out there with no luck, that’s where we come in to do the hard work for you! So, fret over this problem no more and take your pick at the most delicious fudge recipes.

1. No-Fail Orange Creamsicle Fudge

The beauty about making your own fudge is that it can transform you into any paradise you can think of, adding hints of cinnamon can take you to a nostalgic family Christmas event you went to three years ago.

Adding hints of vanilla, and nuts may remind you of a special autumn camping trip you once went on. And adding orange can help you escape to a summer paradise abroad with this no-fail orange creamsicle fudge by Inside Brew Crew Life.

This no-fail fudge is easy to make and can be topped with sugar, orange candies, or anything else you can think of to make it extra special! Something as simple as adding a small amount of orange extract and a swirl of color to achieve these beautifully decorated orange creamsicle fudge pieces.

2. Creamsicle Fudge Recipe

The clue is in the name isn’t it, creamsicle fudge. It sounds like a baker’s dream wonderland where one recipe has been created from the most desirable parts of their dreams, containing every perfected recipe known to man-

kind! When we think of fudge we imagine a creamy, thick delicacy, laced with our favorite flavors combinations. Well, Frugal Family Home Recipes has got it down to the T when it comes to creamsicle fudge!

Fudge recipes are so easy because typically they contain only three ingredients or more. And they almost, turn out pretty well every time because the cooking process is simple, just watch it until it’s creamed together. And if you’re not a fan of the tangy orange flavor, you can just add a little extract and food coloring for a more neutral orange taste!

3. Easy Creamsicle Fudge Recipe

We love desserts that can be made in a microwave as well as on the stove to make your life just that little bit easier.

It’s a no-bake, orange zesty, need I say, dreamsicle Fudge dessert with swirls of orange which make it the most picturesque type of creamsicle fudge. Its made with four ingredients and melting frosting and white chocolate is pretty much the only complex instruction you need to follow. And it’s far from being complex!

Microwave for 90 seconds at roughly 70% power and stir very well to obtain this fudge recipe for yourself. Once you’ve chilled for several hours in the tray, you’ll have yourself a new favorite creamsicle fudge recipe that can be passed onto friends, family, and even strangers if someone new has just come into your life and you want to gift them a homemade recipe!

4. Orange Creamsicle Fudge Recipe

Orange Creamsicle Fudge Recipe (Tastemade)
Source: Tastemade

This orange creamsicle fudge recipe by Tastemade is the perfect family fun bake for any age, as well as involving the kids in the baking process! As long as they’re supervised, this recipe contains minimal ingredients so they can have fun whilst learning about the art of being a baker!

The topping decorations are so fun to add and if they’re finding the fudge making too hard at first, they can still 100% get involved in the toppings.

White chocolate and sweetened condensed milk are added to a microwave bowl and heated for 30-second intervals at a time, so it’s so easy for children to get the hang of and is safe.

The only thing you need to keep an eye on is if the dough starts releasing oils, continue mixing until it all comes back together. Try adding sprinkles, dried fruits, chocolate chips, and any other cute topping you or the kids can think of.

5. Marshmallow Creamsicle Fudge

This creative take on a classic creamsicle fudge recipe has been made by Can Can Dancer and they only use five ingredients to get the job done!

They start off with white chocolate chips melted in the microwave, and then the remaining frosting, tang drink mix, food coloring, and mini marshmallows are stirred into the mix. It doesn’t get any simpler than that.

If you didn’t think creamsicle fudge could get any sweeter, think again! This recipe uses the mini marshmallows to add texture and sweetness to an already marvelous fudge recipe so you can get creative in making your own creations.

Marshmallows or not! And if marshmallows are not your thing, try other flavors and textures to come up with the wildest, and tastiest creamsicle fudge recipe that is entirely your own.

6. Orange Creamsicle Fudge

When we think of dreamy fudge, square or rectangular-sized shapes come to mind, and whilst these shapes are what make fudge so spectacular to enjoy as the bite-size pieces are very addictive, why not try out something a little different today? Low Carb So Simple has come up with small, round shapes for their fudge recipe and we just love how cute they are!

This fudge recipe is so versatile that it can be made using silicone chocolate molds to make beautiful coral-colored fudge pieces with a burst of orange tangy flavors.

They can also be made into adorable popsicles for children to enjoy at tea parties or as a tasty snack in the middle of the day for yourself! You really cannot go wrong with this recipe as however, it turns out, you’ll have a wonderful treat for your loved ones to enjoy that you made from home.

7. Orange Creamsicle Fudge Bites

This recipe by Tasty Kitchen has more of a lengthy ingredients list to go by, however, the method is the same as every other creamsicle fudge recipe out there and is as easy as pie!

These creamsicle fudge pieces are dipped in a specially made melted chocolate and left to set, and then it’s up to you to sprinkle any chocolate flakes, pieces of minuscule shavings on them to finish them off.

This recipe is packed full of extracts, food colorings, and heavy creams for a rich, soft fudge that will have you coming back to make it again throughout the year.

It will be your go-to recipe whenever you fancy something sweet and light, whether it’s on the weekend, or as a midnight snack. These fudge bites hit the sweet spot just enough to send you on your way through your day.

8. White Chocolate Orange Creamsicle Fudge

Orange and vanilla go hand in hand when baking as they’re two very different, but sweet flavors. The orange brings that zesty taste to your tongue, and the vanilla is just a delight to be around in any recipe. Vanilla is the friend who is always there for you and in this case, it really is.

This creamsicle fudge recipe by The Girl Can Bake takes less than 15 minutes to prepare and the quicker you make fudge the better!

Not only because fudge needs to be made fast to set correctly, but also so you can enjoy it sooner! The less waiting around time, the better when it comes to soft, light fudges that melt in the mouth upon first taste.

Even if you’re not a white chocolate lover, the vanilla and orange flavors overpower it anyway so you don’t have to worry about any sickly after tastes.

9. Ali’s Orange Creamsicle Fudge

Ali’s Orange Creamsicle Fudge (Just A Pinch Recipes)
Source: Just a Pinch

We’ve found you a lighter-than-air fudge that does taste exactly like a creamsicle! The rich color comes straight from combining yellow and red food colorings to get that cute clementine shade!

With this recipe, you could have so much fun with the overall color as if you’re more of a blood orange shade lover, or a lemon-infused orange, the food coloring can achieve these shades. It’s not a huge deal with creamsicle fudge to get the perfect orange shade, but if you want to be picky, why not?

Remember to reserve one cup of your mixture for the topping as it will resemble clouds settling on top of an even lighter fudge delight! Be experimental too if you want half the fudge mixture to be this lighter fluffier consistency!

10. Classic Orange Creamsicle Fudge

Source: 12 Tomatoes

We’ve never come across such a fantastic creamsicle fudge recipe that only has four individual ingredients. Food coloring, extract, white chocolate, and vanilla frosting. If these are the only ingredients you have left in your pantry, why not try this recipe by 12 Tomatoes who have done the thinking for you!

These creamsicle fudge recipes take us straight back to our childhoods with the tangy and sweet citrus flavors and that creamy vanilla core that we admire so much.

Don’t wait for a second longer to let this fudge take you back to your childhood as it’s worth the energy of getting up to make! As if it takes much energy to do so, but you may have had a long day, so we’ve kept this recipe to the minimum.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do You Make Orange Creamsicle Fudge?

Well, if you’re still stumped after reading this article, we’ll make it short and simple for you. You can achieve a delicious creamsicle fudge by adding your ingredients into a bowl and microwaving carefully to get a soft, creamy fudge texture that when set in the fridge for a few hours, can be eaten immediately.

Combine white chocolate, vanilla frosting, extracts, and food coloring to achieve the easiest recipe.

How Do You Make Fudge Swirls?

Usually, the orange fudge mix should be poured into the bottom of your pan, then drop your spoonfuls of white fudge into the mix and drag a knife, or the end of a spoon if that’s all you’ve got, through the mixture in different directions, until you achieve your perfect orange creamsicle fudge. Don’t forget to let it set in the fridge after!

In Summary

Take a bite of orange and vanilla- refreshing yet comforting. So there you have it, whether you relate to the creamsicle ice-cream treat or the creamsicle cocktail, these creamsicle fudge recipes will satiate that craving.

For more fun and easy fudge recipes, have a read of these:


Hi, I'm Sarah and welcome to Call Me Fudge! From a younger age I've always pottered about in the kitchen and even selling my fudge in the high school grounds. Cooking and baking to me is like second nature and I want to share this passion with you.

Recent Posts